Skip main navigation

Natalie Carey

EXIT Realty Achieve
Contact Natalie

Recent Sales

Skip to the end of the carousel
  • $602,500
    3 bd3 ba1,586 sqft Commack, NY
    3 bd3 ba1,586 sqft
    Commack, NY
    Sold 1 day ago
    BuyerSeller
    12 Crabapple Lane, Commack, NY, 11725
  • $440,000
    3 bd2 ba1,332 sqft Middle Island, NY
    3 bd2 ba1,332 sqft
    Middle Island, NY
    Sold 14 days ago
    Seller
    6 Amesworth Court, Middle Island, NY, 11953
  • $1,150,000
    4 bd3 ba1,985 sqft Commack, NY
    4 bd3 ba1,985 sqft
    Commack, NY
    Sold 3 months ago
    Buyer
    5 Long House Way, Commack, NY, 11725
  • $785,000
    4 bd3 ba2,254 sqft Stony Brook, NY
    4 bd3 ba2,254 sqft
    Stony Brook, NY
    Sold 4 months ago
    Buyer
    17 Dogwood Drive, Stony Brook, NY, 11790
  • $665,000
    4 bd2 ba1,850 sqft East Northport, NY
    4 bd2 ba1,850 sqft
    East Northport, NY
    Sold 6 months ago
    Buyer
    1 Tamarack Street, East Northport, NY, 11731
Skip to the beginning of the carousel
11
Sales last 12 months
67
Total sales
$180K-$1.6M
Price range
$711K
Average price

Get to know Natalie Carey

Real Estate Salesperson

Specialties
Buyer's AgentListing AgentNew ConstructionSenior Communities
7 Years of experience

Natalie Carey's listings & sales (67)

For Sale
For Rent
Sold
This map can show the most recent 100 listings and 100 sales. Review all listings and sales below.

For Sale

Active listings data currently unavailable.

Sold (67)

Address
Sold date
Closing price
Represented
Flag Sale
12/17/2025$602,500Buyer and Seller
12/4/2025$440,000Seller
9/10/2025$1,150,000Buyer
8/7/2025$785,000Buyer
6/26/2025$665,000Buyer

Natalie Carey's reviews (12)

Skip to the end of the carousel
  • 5.0
    • 3/15/2025
    • Mike Zeck

    Bought a Single Family home in 2025 in Mount sinai, NY.

    Natalie helped us a great deal in finding a home in this market. We got a 4 bedroom house under our max budget leaving room to make our own updates and increase the value...
    Natalie helped us a great deal in finding a home in this market. We got a 4 bedroom house under our max budget leaving room to mak...
    5.0
    • 6/11/2024
    • dmats102122

    Bought and sold a Townhouse home in 2024 in Port jefferson, NY.

    We were originally very uncertain about the pricing of our home and needed a quick sale. Natalie marketed the house to perfection and got our home sold in a few days for ...
    We were originally very uncertain about the pricing of our home and needed a quick sale. Natalie marketed the house to perfection ...
  • 5.0
    • 3/15/2023
    • tazrois

    Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2022 in Central islip, NY.

    Natalie is an outstanding realtor. She successfully managed to sell my house, my daughters condo and find and purchase a house of our dreams simultaneously. This was no e...
    Natalie is an outstanding realtor. She successfully managed to sell my house, my daughters condo and find and purchase a house of ...
    5.0
    • 8/4/2022
    • rebeccascands

    Bought a Single Family home in 2022 in Hauppauge, NY.

    Very accommodating and easy to work with. Easy buying process with assistance along the way. Made recommendations for inspectors and closing attorney. Very responsive t...
    Very accommodating and easy to work with. Easy buying process with assistance along the way. Made recommendations for inspectors ...
  • 5.0
    • 9/9/2021
    • acodlivak

    Sold a Single Family home in 2021 in Commack, NY.

    Natalie made a difficult job for two seniors easy. She sold our house in one day and did everything she said she would do. She impressed us with her knowledge of the Co...
    Natalie made a difficult job for two seniors easy. She sold our house in one day and did everything she said she would do. She i...
    5.0
    • 9/4/2021
    • dhwasserman7

    Sold a Single Family home in 2021 in Commack, NY.

    Working with Natalie was a great experience! She was a great partner in both selling our house and helping us purchase our forever home. She did not push us to rush any d...
    Working with Natalie was a great experience! She was a great partner in both selling our house and helping us purchase our forever...
  • 5.0
    • 8/16/2020
    • licok510

    Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Hauppauge, NY.

    Natalie was very knowledgeable and always available if we had any we questions. She was with us until the closing to make sure everything was going as it should. Thank y...
    Natalie was very knowledgeable and always available if we had any we questions. She was with us until the closing to make sure ev...
    5.0
    • 7/7/2020
    • zuser20170910170703133

    Bought a Single Family home in 2019 in Commack, NY.

    Natalie was a true professional throughout our house hunt. She worked with is for over a year to find the perfect home. She was never pushy and was always flexible and av...
    Natalie was a true professional throughout our house hunt. She worked with is for over a year to find the perfect home. She was ne...
  • 5.0
    • 11/21/2019
    • zuser20170726075937866

    Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2019 in Commack, NY.

    I can't say enough about Natalie Carey - she is fantastic! She handled two transactions for us and did so with professionalism and patience. She is down to earth, easy ...
    I can't say enough about Natalie Carey - she is fantastic! She handled two transactions for us and did so with professionalism an...
    5.0
    • 11/19/2019
    • tammie4nys

    Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2019 in Huntington, NY.

    If you are looking for your dream home, reach out to Natalie Carey. Natalie helped our family secure our forever home. Natalie will help you research the perfect home fo...
    If you are looking for your dream home, reach out to Natalie Carey. Natalie helped our family secure our forever home. Natalie wi...
Skip to the beginning of the carousel
Add a review

Service areas (0)

    Natalie Carey

    EXIT Realty Achieve
    11sales last 12 months
    67total sales
    $180K-$1.6Mprice range
    $711Kaverage price
    7years of experience